Content Window Initialization
Community Include

City Council Minutes

(back to Archive Overview)

City of Northville Approved on 8/4/03 as amended
CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING MINUTES
July 21, 2003

Mayor Johnson called the meeting to order with the Pledge of Allegiance at 7:30 p.m. in the Northville City Hall Council Chambers, 215 West Main Street, Northville, Michigan.

ROLL CALL:

Present: Mayor Christopher Johnson, Mayor Pro Tem Carolann Ayers, Councilmembers Kevin Hartshorne, Jerome Mittman and Thomas Swigart

Absent: None

Also Present: City Manager Gary Word, Assistant City Manager/Finance Director Nicolette Bateson, Director of Public Works James Gallogly, City Clerk Dianne Massa, Parks and Recreation Director Traci Sincock, DDA Executive Director Lori Ward (arrived 7:40 p.m.), Arts Commissioners Ken Naigus and Sonia Swigart, local artist David Barr, Reporters from the Northville Record, Northville Journal and the Community Crier, and seven citizens.

PRESENTATIONS:

A. Citizen Comments None

B. Historical Monument Proposal / Northville Arts Commission

The Arts Commission is proposing to commission local artist David Barr to link the past and present through the creation of an artistic historical monument for the City of Northville. The proposal calls for the creation of several pieces, which would be located on or near Baseline Road, throughout several communities in Michigan, including Northville. It is proposed that the Northville monument be located in an area at or near Hillside Middle School. Mr. Barr envisions a granite surveyor’s pole that uses natural light to create shadows pointing to informative markers located along Baseline Road. The markers would provide an educational experience, which would encourage people to explore the significance of Baseline Road in the history of surveying. The Arts Commission and Mr. Barr hopes to engage children from various communities to assist in determining the content of the educational markers.

City Council gave the project their support, commenting that it will offer a wonderful educational opportunity for children from various communities. It was also stated that the Historic District Commission was interested in the project’s correlation of history and art. Since it is likely that the Northville piece will be located on school property, Staff was directed to assist the Arts Commission in contacting the Northville Public School District for their support and assistance.

C. Ash Tree Reformation / Proposed Dog Park Sculpture

Fred Shadko, 47040 Timberline, Northville, is interested in donating a wooden sculpture to the Dog Park. The proposed sculpture would be carved from a hardwood tree log, possibly from one of the many Ash trees destroyed by the Emerald Ash Borer. Mr. Shadko offered photos that illustrated several of the wood sculptures located on his property. It was questioned whether a wood sculpture would be an appropriate use of the contaminated Ash trees (unknown at this time). City Council expressed their support of this project, provided that sufficient research indicated that the Emerald Ash Borer can be completely removed from the Ash tree log. Otherwise, an alternative tree log should be used.

APPROVAL OF AGENDA / CONSENT AGENDA:

"Oakland County West Nile Virus Reimbursement Fund Request" was added to the agenda as New Business 9C.

Motion Ayers, seconded by Mittman to approve the agenda and consent agenda as amended. Consent agenda as follows:

Approve City Council Minutes:

Regular Meeting of July 7, 2003

Approve Bills List: Checks #32743 to #32828 and Checks #32829 to #32975

Receive Board and Commission Minutes:

Beautification Commission: 6/10/03

Board of Zoning Appeals: 2/5/03

Downtown Development Authority: 5/13/03

Historic District Commission: 4/16/03, 5/21/03, 6/18/03

Parks and Recreation: 5/14/03, 6/11/03

Receive Departmental Reports:

Parks and Recreation: 5/03, 6/03

Youth Assistance: 6/03

Board and Commission Appointments:

  • Housing Appeals Board: (reappointment) John Genitti – alternate member
  • Motion carried unanimously.

    RESOLUTIONS AND ORDINANCES:

    A. Resolution / Intent to Issue Tax Increment Limited Tax Obligation Bonds

    For several years, the Downtown Development Authority (DDA) has discussed parking expansion in downtown Northville. This year, the DDA directed Staff to proceed with a parking expansion plan that would impact Parking Lot #2 and Parking Lot #3 (Marquis Lot). The proposed funding source for this project is a limited tax obligation bond, which would be repaid with tax-increment funds from the DDA. Revenues from parking credits, related to new development, would provide supplemental funding for the project, if needed.

    At its July 8, 2003 meeting, the DDA adopted a resolution requesting that the City proceed with issuing tax increment/limited tax obligation bonds. The bond amount is to be $5,000,000. The City’s Bond Counsel and Financial Advisor recommended that a higher amount than budgeted be included in the notice of sale. This is considered prudent when bonds are issued during the project design process. The actual bond obligation amount would likely be lower than the amount published, but cannot be higher.

    The next step in the process for issuing tax obligation bonds is for the City Council to adopt a Notice of Intent Resolution and publish the Notice of Intent, giving rise to a 45-day right of referendum. During this 45-day period, the City Council may adopt a Bond Authorizing Resolution.

    Council Comments / Discussion: Discussion ensued relative to parking expansion, issuing tax limited obligation bonds, and repayment of the bonds through tax increment funds generated through the Downtown Development Authority (DDA). The following questions were raised:

    What is the length of time that the various boards and commissions have considered the issue regarding parking expansion within the downtown area? Answer: Parking expansion in the downtown area has been actively discussed by the DDA for at least seven years. The City Council and the Planning Commission have actively discussed this issue for at least two years. Parking expansion has been a part of the DDA budget process for several years, with funds set aside to specifically address parking expansion. Further, the need for additional downtown parking has been conveyed to the Parking Committee by the downtown businesses and visitors to the community.

    Have numerous parking expansion concepts been reviewed? Answer: Yes, numerous ideas were introduced and subsequently narrowed down to five parking expansion concepts.

    Would new development occur in the Main/Dunlap/Wing street area without the addition of a parking deck? Answer: It is unlikely that significant development would occur in this area as the developer would be unable to provide the required on-site parking. Further, without redevelopment, the City’s tax base would erode.

    An explanation of the two financing options available to the City was requested. Answer: Two types of bonds are available to the City: Limited Tax Obligation Bonds and Unlimited Tax Obligation Bonds. The City’s AA bond rating brings the City into an area where the limited tax obligation bond is appealing. Since the interest rate is close to that of the unlimited tax obligation bond (less than $500 annually), it is not advantageous to the City to pursue unlimited tax bond financing. It was stated that limited tax obligation bonds were designed for this type of project and that the bonds would be repaid with tax-increment finance (TIF) revenues generated by the DDA.

    Could DDA funds be used to finance other projects located outside of the DDA? Answer: Under state statute, DDA funds must stay within the DDA and cannot be used outside the DDA’s geographic area. The parking deck will be located within the DDA boundaries and the bonds would be repaid through TIF revenues generated by the DDA.

    Does the current parking deck design conform to the City’s Zoning Ordinance? Answer: Yes. Under the City’s Zoning Ordinance, the parking deck may be built at a height not to exceed 42 feet and the proposed deck is no higher than 35 feet. The requirements of the Zoning Ordinance would be met and variances under the current design are not necessary.

    Brief discussion focused on the statute that allows tax-increment financing (TIF), school tax revenues, and an explanation of the effects of Proposal A on school district funding. The following questions were raised:

    Should the bonds be issued, would the various taxing jurisdictions need to be notified to express their interest in participating in the TIF capture? Answer: Since the parking deck project is based on the current DDA boundaries, notification to the various taxing jurisdictions is not required. However, the various taxing jurisdictions would need to be notified if the DDA and tax-increment financing district boundaries were expanded.

    Would the various taxing jurisdictions have the option to pull out of the TIF district as it pertains to the capture of revenues associated with issuing the tax limited obligation bonds? Answer: No, parking expansion is a legitimate use of DDA operating funds and TIF revenue may be used toward repayment of debt incurred to expand parking within the DDA. The amount of revenue generated through the TIF district does not change and the sale of bonds does not allow the DDA to collect additional revenues through the TIF district.

    When does the 45 day right of referendum begin? Answer: The 45 day period begins on the date the Notice of Intent is published. This is expected to be on July 24, 2003.

    What is the number of signatures needed to reflect 10% of the registered electors in the City? Answer: Approximately 470.

    Additional comments included:

    The City of Northville was one of the first communities to use the DDA mechanism to assist in revitalizing the downtown. Downtown Development Authorities and the use of the TIF financing tool exist for the purpose of improving public elements in order to encourage private development. With private development comes the TIF district revenues used to assist in repaying the public debt. The parking deck expansion project is an affordable project that would continue to promote the vitality and growth of the downtown.

    The current DDA will expire around 2009 – 2010 and the parking expansion project will require an amendment to extend the life of the DDA. It was further stated that even without this project, it would seem to be a positive effect to the community and to the downtown to extend the end date of the DDA.

    Within the DDA and through the use of the tax-increment financing mechanism, it can be argued that the other taxing jurisdictions have not lost any money as they never had the money initially. The growth of the SEV within the downtown encouraged the prosperity of Northville, which assisted in repaying other bonds of this type. The prosperity of the downtown has helped to increase the value of the community as a whole.

    Motion Mittman, seconded by Ayers to adopt the Notice of Intent Resolution and direct City Staff to proceed with publishing the Notice of Intent. Yes: Mittman, Ayers, Swigart, Johnson. No: Hartshorne. Motion carried.

    Mayor Pro Tem Ayers questioned why Councilmember Hartshorne did not support the motion to publish the Notice of Intent. Councilmember Hartshorne stated that his "no" vote was the final chance the public had to object to the proposal as it exists today. Mr. Hartshorne acknowledged that, through the right of referendum, the public has a voice in the bond issue but not in the final project development plan. Mr. Hartshorne stated that, although he does not have a problem with the bond issue, he has reservations with the project in its present form. He further stated that his "no" vote represented the only opportunity to demonstrate the wishes of those who feel these projects are not appropriate. He felt a "yes" vote would infer his support for the project as a whole.

    NEW BUSINESS:

    A. Proposed Purchase of Town Clock Chime Master System

    Many years ago, the City purchased a chime system for the town clock located in the downtown on Main Street. Several years ago, the system required service at an approximate cost of $3,000. Since the unit was not placed in a warm building, the manufacturer stated that problems would persist with the City’s unit. This has proven to be the case and the unit has not functioned properly for the last two years. The unit is no longer serviceable and the manufacturer will no longer warrant its services.

    Staff researched the available chime systems, and found that a system manufactured and sold by Chime Master Systems has no moving parts, offers 100% digital bell recordings, programmable level control, built-in calendar, battery back up, a five-year warranty and free technical programming support. The watertight cabinet used to house the current chime system is sufficient for housing the new unit. The system can be programmed to play several kinds of music, including secular holiday music and patriotic songs on all federal holidays. Funding for this project would come from funds remaining in the DDA FY03 Street Furnishings Budget.

    Council Comments / Discussion: A question was raised pertaining to the sound quality and it was noted that it was possible that the speakers may need to be replaced. It was suggested that the City’s website be used as an avenue to afford residents the opportunity to vote on the music choices.

    Motion Swigart, seconded by Hartshorne to approve the purchase of a 2003 Millennium Carillon System from Chime Master Systems of Ohio in the amount of $6,000. Further, the system is to be programmed and installed before the 2003 holiday season (November 14, 2003). Motion carried unanimously.

    B. Proposed Bid Award / Parks and Recreation Catalog Printing

    On July 15, 2003, the Parks and Recreation Department received bids for the annual printing and mailing of the 2003-04 Parks and Recreation activity catalog, which are summarized below.

    Bid Amount Ad Sales Glossy

    Vendor Annual Commissions Cover

    Webco Press $15,600 60% owner $10,170

    40% vendor (using Skene-Delonis)

    Webco Press (alternate bid) $14,175 (50 lb. paper)

    Robot Printing $31,422 no bid no bid

    Nu-Ad $17,685 no bid no bid

    Skene-Delonis no bid 60% owner no bid

    40% vendor

    Webco Press submitted an alternate bid of $14,175 using 50 lb. paper, which is acceptable to the Parks and Recreation Department. The budgeted amount for the catalog printing is $20,000, with $12,000 of the cost obtained by advertising sales. As such, Webco’s bid offers a favorable budget impact.

    Motion Swigart, seconded by Ayers to award the 2003-04 Parks and Recreation activity catalog printing bid, along with advertising sales, to Webco Press in the amount of $14,175. Motion carried unanimously.

    C. Oakland County West Nile Virus Reimbursement Fund Request

    Both Oakland and Wayne County have adopted programs designed to assist local communities in funding expenses incurred with implementing a program to control the spread of West Nile Virus. The City is eligible to receive approximately $1,000 from each county. The Oakland County program requires the community to adopt a resolution in order to apply for expense reimbursement. The City’s mosquito control plan would be a two step approach, which would: 1) Utilize the summer addition of "Words from Works" to educate Northville residents on how to minimize their risk to West Nile Virus; and 2) Deposit methoprene larvicide briquettes in the City’s stormwater catch basins. It is estimated that one briquette can treat a catch basin for 150 days. The City ordered approximately 600 briquettes at a cost of $3.00 each.

    Council Comments/Discussion: Questions were raised relative to environmental and safety issues and when the briquettes would be delivered (two weeks). A final comment suggested educating residents on the use of bat houses to assist in controlling the mosquito population.

    Motion Hartshorne, seconded by Mittman to adopt a resolution authorizing an expense reimbursement request from the Oakland County West Nile Virus Fund. Motion carried unanimously.

    COMMUNICATIONS:

    A. Mayor and Council Communications

    Ayers requested updates on the Northville Community Park Expansion and the Allen Terrace Renovation projects. It was noted that the Township Board has not made a decision on the proposed expansion plan and has called a special meeting on July 31st relative to this issue. The Allen Terrace Renovation project was re-bid with favorable results and the proposed bid awards will be presented to the City Council on August 4th. Ayers also requested an update on the progress of the cemetery expansion. It was noted that the trees were removed and the next steps are road construction, fencing, and the plotting of grave sites. The City should be ready to sell these lots by the end of the year.

    Hartshorne noted that in honor of Resident Appreciation Week, Allen Terrace would be hosting an ice cream social on Wednesday, July 23rd at 4:00 p.m.

    Swigart commended the Parks and Recreation Department on their professionalism and ability to rise to the challenge of organizing last weekend’s soccer tournament, in a relatively short timeframe. It is expected that the event organizers (Northville Soccer Association) will reimburse the Recreation Department for the full amount of the costs associated with this event.

    Mittman commented on the Open Space Report, with the suggestion to schedule a working session to review the open space recommendations once the Parks and Recreation Long-Term Strategic Plan has been completed and reviewed. He also questioned the status of revising the cemetery fee structure as it pertains to funding long-term care cemetery expansion (the cemetery will be expanded in phases and the current expansion project is considered phase one). (amended on 8/4/03)

    The DPW Director stated that the South Lexington project is scheduled to begin on Monday. Notification letters were sent to the residents and the project should be completed within eight to ten weeks.

    B. Staff Communications None

     

    There being no further business to come before Council, the meeting was adjourned.

    Adjournment: 8:54 p.m.

    Respectfully submitted,

     

    Dianne Massa

    City Clerk

     






     
    Event Calendar
    Content Window Content Window
    5/15/12 Downtown Development Authority Meeting
    5/15/12 Planning Commission Meeting
    5/16/12 Historic District Commission Meeting
    5/17/12 Farmers' Market
    5/17/12 Northville Senior Advisory Commission Meeting
    More ...

     
     
    News and Announcements

    Now Hiring: Housekeeping for Allen Terrace Senior Apartment Complex.  Click here for details.

    eBill for Utility Billing
    Bills by email are now available to all utility billing customers.
    Click here to sign up.

    Automatic Payment (ACH) for Taxes & Utility Billing
    The City offers Automatic Payment for Utility Billing.
    Click here to sign up.
    The City offers Automatic Payment for Taxes.
    Click here to sign up.

    Roundabout IconHow to Drive a Roundabout
    Visit the State of Michigan website for helpful information on Roundabouts.

    A 1-bedroom is available at
    Allen Terrace

    Call 248-349-8030 for more information or visit the Allen Terrace website.